To be clear, these estimates do not include the fiscal promises Donald Trump made in the run up to the election. These are estimated to add $7.8 trillion to federal debt over the next decade – roughly a 25% increase on current projections, even after including $2.7 trillion of additional revenue raised via import tariffs – a highly questionable revenue source. Unless Donald Trump reneges on his key campaign pledges, the supply of government bonds hitting the market in the years ahead will be even greater than the chart suggests.
Of course, Elon Musk might come to the rescue. He intends to cut at least $2 trillion (30% of 2024 outlays) from federal spending. He might as well have said pigs can fly. Cuts on that scale would be economically dangerous and politically unacceptable to Trump. After all, the electoral coalition that has just returned him to power is the main beneficiary of the 60% of total federal outlays the government transfers each year to pensioners and lower income households.
So what about the bond vigilantes? By the end of 2024, bond investors look likely to have suffered the fourth year of a bond bear market – enough to make anyone grumpy. Now they are being asked to buy record amounts of US government bonds for the next five years. Their likely price? Higher yields.
President Clinton’s adviser James Carville famously said in the 1990s: “I used to think that if there was reincarnation, I wanted to come back as the president or the pope… But now I would like to come back as the bond market. You can intimidate everybody.”
The vigilantes are not back – yet. But this time they would have a much stronger case. The fiscal position is worse and the spectre of inflation has returned. Cyclically, the economy is healthy, but the global order is under severe strain, and US stock market valuations look stretched even assuming falling interest rates and bond yields. Wouldn’t it be the great irony of US politics if Trump and the Republicans – the ideological torch bearers of a small state – preside over America’s first fiscal crisis since the Civil War?