You can’t tax your way out of this

Chancellor Sunak will need a Plan B

The Green Line
Steve Russell
Investment Director

The coronavirus pandemic has hit public finances like a war. Across the world governments have scrambled to offset the economic and social impact of the virus. Huge, and necessary, rises in public spending have pushed government deficits to levels not seen since the two world wars of the twentieth century.

The numbers are enormous: UK government debt now tops £2 trillion1 whilst the US owes an eyewatering $26 trillion.2 The picture is similar across Europe with many other countries also seeing debt/GDP ratios rising to over 100%.3

We think such debt levels are simply too big to be repaid through tax rises. In the UK, increasing everyone’s income tax by 1% would only raise an estimated £5-6 billion.4 Similarly, a 1% rise in VAT would raise about £7 billion.5 Neither of these would make any noticeable dent in this mountain of debt, even doing both would still take 150 years to pay down today’s debts. No wonder Rishi Sunak cancelled his autumn budget – he’s going to need a Plan B.

Fortunately, zero interest rates mean there is no immediate need to repay the debt. But eventually it will need to be tackled. If raising tax won’t do the job, how can governments get deficits down to manageable levels?

Perhaps history can help us. After the first world war Britain opted for austerity and government spending fell by 75%.6 Unemployment soared and the country suffered a deep depression. The medicine worked, but it almost killed the patient. This is simply politically unacceptable in today’s world.

The second world war may hold more clues for today’s policy makers. A combination of rapid post-war economic growth plus a healthy dose of inflation saw deficits fall rapidly. In the 30 years immediately after WWII nominal growth averaged 8.8% – made up of 2.3% real GDP growth and 6.5% inflation.7

This time, however, such levels of economic growth are likely to be harder to achieve. There is no post-war rebuilding boom to come, no peace ‘dividend’. Instead it looks like inflation, not growth, austerity or taxation, will have to do the heavy lifting.

That said, taxes may well still rise. The chancellor may have higher rate income tax in his sights, or capital gains, or even a wealth tax, but this will be for political reasons and will likely be limited in impact.

So, could it be that inflation, not tax, poses the greatest risk to savers today? Perhaps this will turn out to be Rishi Sunak’s Plan B. At Ruffer we think history shows that this is a risk worth protecting against, so over 40% of our portfolios consist of inflation-linked bonds and gold. After all, as Ben Bernanke told the National Economists Club back in November 2002: ‘government has a technology, called a printing press…’

Ruffer Radio: Election 2020
October 2020: All elections are equal. But some elections are more equal than others. In the latest episode of Ruffer Radio, Dr Tim Smith and Alexander Chartres discuss the 2020 race to the White House and explore why this election, in the context of a broader shift in world order, may well be the most important for a generation.
Investment Review
October 2020: Whatever one’s outlook, there have been times in 2020 when the markets seemed to echo one’s innermost thoughts, and times when we shout out like Falstaff, that the whole world has gone mad. The bulls and the bears have had their time in the sun, and their time on the dark face of the moon – what follows is a digested diary of our journey through the year 2020 so far.
MMT on the march?
The response to this economic crisis has moved away from the old monetary regime to one where fiscal policy has become more important.
  1. Office for National Statistics, Public Sector Finances UK July 2020
  2. US Treasury, Debt to the Penny, 30 September 2020 Fiscal Data
  3. Goldman Sachs, 24 March 2020
  4. Institute for Fiscal Studies, September 2020
  5. Ibid
  6. The National Archives
  7. OBR Office for Budget Responsibility, Post-WWII debt reduction, 11 September 2017

Chart source: Ruffer, MacroHistory database, TS Lombard

Past performance is not a guide to future performance, investments can go down as well as up and you may get back less than you originally invested. The information contained in this document does not constitute investment advice or research and should not be used as the basis of any investment decision. References to specific securities are included for the purpose of illustration only, they are not a recommendation to buy or sell.

80 Victoria Street
London SW1E 5JL
31 Charlotte Square
Edinburgh EH2 4ET
103 boulevard Haussman
75008 Paris, France